Just a short and sweet post today, because…well, I got so tied up in sweating with Sven that I overlooked the fact that today was my day to blog. Ah!
MJ and I have both been tossing around story ideas for a couple of different genres as of late. My genre interests, though, don’t venture too far away from involving sex and lots of it—I’m tinkering with both a contemporary “hot” and a couple of short erotics, one of which is paranormal. MJ’s going between a contemporary “hot” and a couple of fantasy/paranormals (one I know is a little steamy, the other she hasn’t spilled the beans on yet).
Anyway, this got me thinking about a couple of things. First of all, someone (honestly can’t remember who) mentioned once, I believe on Divas, that while her writing interests varied genre-wise, her agent had urged her to stick to one as not to mess with her fan base. At first I was miffed—why not spread the wealth? Pick up even more fans by being versatile, right?
Not necessarily. In fact, now that I think about it, that’s why Nora has JD. I mean, sure we all know, as romance writers and avid readers that the two are the same person, but not every average Joe does. My sister-in-law is a huge JD Robb fan, but she despises Nora. Imagine her shock when I broke it to her that the authors were one in the same. If Nora had decided to go off on her Eve Dallas mystery kick (pardon me if I’m wrong…I don’t read them—gasp!) and her dedicated, horse-trainer loving, romance readers (pardon me again…I don’t read Nora either—a crime, I know) weren’t into that kind of thing, they’d stop buying her books. Not entirely, I’m sure, but her readers would likely begin to wonder if they next book they pick up by her would render the same kind of disappointment. Now I am by no means, saying anything that Nora writes is a disappointment—I’m just sayin’, you know?
Anyhow, it goes the other direction, too. Mystery/detective loving readers, like my sister-in-law, might miss out on the apparently wonderful In Death books if Nora had written them as Nora for the simple fact that they wouldn’t think a romance novelist capable of producing a worthwhile mystery read and would have never picked them up to begin with.
So, you say, if you wanna cross genres…get a pen name. Woohoo. Problem solved. *smile* Sure, we could do that. But let’s be real here—we’re not all Nora. Not all of us have the capability of producing gobs of fabulous material every year. The norm is probably somewhere in the range of a couple of novels a year, if we’re lucky. So, if I write an erotic and an inspirational (haha, funny, I know) this year, I’m only producing one book a year for each of my fan groups. And, if my fans are anything like me, they’re going to get impatient waiting around for another novel and they’ll likely pick another, more productive author to follow. Now, again, I’m not saying that there’s anything wrong with writing only one novel a year… *wink*
So, back to the diva whose agent had told her to stick with what she was already really good at and established in. I see her point perfectly now and I encourage those of you who have varying interests to consider it. Not saying there’s a right or wrong answer—some might want a really strong, genre-specific fan base and steady sales, some might want to express themselves across several genres simply because they love writing, caring less about sales and their fans than they do the writing experience itself.
Of course, we’d all love to follow in the footsteps of La Nora and, while it’s not for me, it’s a fine aspiration to have. I, personally, think I’m best sticking to one genre, at least right now while I’m trying to get my foot in the door…somewhere. Hmm. On the other hand, I might be better off trying my hand in different genres to find what I’m best at… Gah!
What do you think? Is it best, more important perhaps, to be true to your interests and write whatever suits you? Or is best to keep your interests genre-specific? Is it really necessary to choose?
(LOL! So much for short and sweet, huh?)
~Ally